The 12 Best Kitchen Remodeling Contractors in Columbus, OH

Jump to List

A home is more than just a building that you live in. Your home is your place of refuge and respite from the world we live in, and your kitchen is the heartbeat of your home. Entrusting a kitchen renovation project to a stranger is a huge decision.  

Will they provide quality products and services?  

Will they listen to your needs and vision for your kitchen?  

Will they take care of your home the way you would? 

Contractors generally have a bad reputation, and honestly, a lot of that reputation has been earned. So with every home remodeling company claiming that they are the #1 kitchen remodeler in Columbus, how do you know which company you should entrust with your project?

Obviously, we want to jump up and down and tell you that JSB Home Solutions is the best choice for a kitchen remodel in Columbus, OH! And while we have been a family-owned business since 1978 and have a 4.33-star rating with an A+ rating by the Better Business Bureau (BBB), you’re not here to read all about why we think we’re great.

Because of this, we have not included JSB Home Solutions in the list. We want you to have all the tools you need to choose the best remodeling company for your project, even if it is not us. It is more important that we present you with honest, complete, and unbiased information, regardless of who you choose to hire to renovate your kitchen.

And while we would love to work with you in creating your dream kitchen, that doesn’t automatically make us the best fit for your needs. You shouldn’t have to compromise your vision to fit our business. There are three major categories of remodeling to consider as you plan any remodeling project.

1. Facelift: In a facelift remodel, a new skin, cover, or veneer is applied over what is already in the space. Facelift remodeling can also be called Same-Day, One-Day, or Over-Existing remodeling. Should you want a fast and simple update to what you currently have in your home, a same-day remodel would best suit your needs. 
2. Remove & Replace: We here at JSB are primarily a remove & replace remodeler, meaning that we remove what is currently in the space and replace it with new materials. Typically, this does not involve major structural changes to the home.
3. Design-Build: Design-build remodeling, also called custom or full-scale remodeling, is bounded only by your imagination and the skills of the team you hire. The sky is the limit with design-build. 

We are passionate about educating homeowners like you about the kitchen remodel process to ensure you make the best choice for your home renovation project. We have spent hours compiling information from the company’s online reviews, websites, and BBB profiles to compare them head-to-head so that you don’t have to!

Without further ado, these are the top 12 kitchen remodelers in Columbus, Ohio ranked by their Google star rating. Tie-breakers are determined by which company has the higher number of ratings.

1. Kitchen Tune-Up of Columbus North

“Freshen up, fix up, brighten up with the experts at Kitchen Tune-Up. No matter what service works well for your space, we’ll make it look and feel transformed.”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 5 (135)
• Remodeling Category: Same-Day
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 10 (35 years nationally)
• Franchise or Local: International Franchise; independently owned and operated
• BBB Accredited: No
• BBB Rating: –
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: –
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 5 (4)
• Showroom: Not Listed
• Kitchen Services: Cabinet Redooring, Cabinet Painting, Cabinet Refacing, New Cabinets, Granite Countertop Maintenance, Cabinet Organization

2. Kitchen Solvers of Columbus

“Our professionals work with you to create a kitchen remodel that fits your style and budget. We guide you through an effortless process from the initial consultation to the finished “wow” feeling!”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 5 (62)
• Remodeling Category: Remove & Replace
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 11 (42 years nationally)
• Franchise or Local: National Franchise; independently owned and operated
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: A+
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: – (0)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 4.8 (22)
• Showroom: Yes
• Kitchen Services: Cabinet Refacing, New Cabinets, Countertops, Backsplashes

3. Scott Hall Remodeling

“We have many years of experience in designing and working with our clients. We can create any type of customized interior remodel to meet your specific needs.”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 5 (51)
• Remodeling Category: Design-Build
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 25
• Franchise or Local: Local
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: A+
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: 5 (1)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 4.9 (152)
• Showroom: Yes
• Kitchen Services: All kitchen components

4. Simple Bath + Kitchen

“We purpose-built Simple Bath + Kitchen to remodel your bathroom and kitchen.  It’s that focus that enables us to complete your project so quickly and without compromise.”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 5 (25)
• Remodeling Category: Remove & Replace
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 12
• Franchise or Local: Local
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: A+
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: 5 (1)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 4.9 (218)
• Showroom: Yes
• Kitchen Services: Cabinets, Stone & Laminate Countertops, Wood & Laminate & Vinyl Flooring, Tile Backsplashes, Lighting & Fixtures

5. Nicolson Builders

“Whether you’re looking to begin your next project or if this is your first renovation, trust Nicholson to guide you through a careful transformation of your most valuable possession – your home!”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 4.9 (63)
• Remodeling Category: Design-Build
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 21
• Franchise or Local: Local
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: A+
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: – (0)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 4.9 (173)
• Showroom: Yes
• Kitchen Services: All Kitchen Components, Small Projects Division, Commercial Remodeling

6. The Creative Kitchen Company

“Kitchen remodeling can be overwhelming. But our team of skilled craftsmen and dedicated project managers, together with a proven streamlined process, can provide a breathtaking kitchen remodel that is built to last a lifetime.”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 4.9 (24)
• Remodeling Category: Remove & Replace
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 20
• Franchise or Local: Local
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: A+
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: 4.95 (22)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 4.9 (5)
• Showroom: Yes
• Kitchen Services: Cabinet Refacing, New Cabinets, Flooring, Lighting, Additional Options

7. J.S. Brown & Co.

“As a full-service custom residential remodeling company and a licensed, bonded, and insured general contractor, J.S. Brown & Co. has built a solid reputation for quality workmanship. Our mission is to satisfy our customers’ needs by offering a better experience and end result at a value that can’t be matched anywhere else.”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 4.8 (39)
• Remodeling Category: Design-Build
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 46
• Franchise or Local: Local
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: A+
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: – (0)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 4.6 (39)
• Showroom: Yes
• Kitchen Services: All kitchen components

8. SemBro Designs  – Columbus,  OH

“At SemBro Designs in Columbus, we take pride in bringing your kitchen dreams to life. When it comes to kitchen remodels, our team is dedicated to transforming your culinary space into a kitchen that perfectly suits your lifestyle.”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 4.6 (119)
• Remodeling Category: Design-Build
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 14
• Franchise or Local: Ohio Franchise
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: A+
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: 5 (4)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 4.8 (73)
• Showroom: Yes
• Kitchen Services: Semi-Custom Cabinets, Granite Countertops, Flooring, Hardware, Appliances

9. The Cleary Company

“It’s the perfect place to gather with your family or friends and for that reason most of us want to have a WOW factor or focal point, but more importantly, your kitchen needs to function for your lifestyle.”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 4.6 (29)
• Remodeling Category: Design-Build
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 30
• Franchise or Local: Local
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: A+
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: – (0)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 5 (27)
• Showroom: Yes
• Kitchen Services: All kitchen components

10. Kitchen Saver

“Kitchen Saver® can give you the kitchen you’ve always wanted by using our Custom Cabinet Renewal process, a faster, more valuable option to kitchen remodeling. Our design team will discuss your needs, and you’ll be able to choose from numerous style and color combinations to create a custom look for your kitchen.”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 4.4 (85)
• Remodeling Category: Same-Day
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 23
• Franchise or Local: Midwest Franchise
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: A
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: 2.25 (4)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 4.2 (12)
• Showroom: Not Listed
• Kitchen Services: Cabinet Refacing, New Cabinets, Countertops, Lighting, Sinks, and More

11. Dave Fox Remodeling

“We do kitchen design and renovation projects of all different shapes, sizes, and styles. After all, the kitchen is the heart of the home.”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 4.4 (77)
• Remodeling Category: Design-Build
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 42
• Franchise or Local: Local
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: A+
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: 2.33 (5)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 4.4 (131)
• Showroom: Yes
• Kitchen Services: All Kitchen Components

12. Kitchen Kraft

“Kitchen Kraft is a complete design-build kitchen & bath remodeling firm serving central Ohio providing white glove attention from the beginning design phase through installation. Our philosophy at Kitchen Kraft is to make home remodeling convenient. We are your one-stop shop for kitchen design, bathroom remodeling, let’s do the whole floor.”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 4.2 (19)
• Remodeling Category: Design-Build
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 29
• Franchise or Local: Local
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: A+
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: – (0)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 4.2 (26)
• Showroom: Yes
• Kitchen Services: All Kitchen Components

How do you choose the right kitchen remodeling contractor for you?

With over 150 search results for “kitchen remodelers in Columbus, OH”, choosing a contractor for your kitchen renovation feels impossible. We have highlighted 12 of the top kitchen remodelers in Columbus and compared their remodel category, years of experience, services, and online ratings to help you determine what to look for in a reputable remodeler.

With nearly 100 kitchen renovations in 2023, our information would be incomplete if we didn’t tell you who JSB Home Solutions is a good fit for. While ratings, reviews, services, and years in business are important, they don’t represent the whole picture. Principles of integrity, trust, and quality craftsmanship have guided our company’s founder, president, and namesake. We are proud of our name, reputation, and heritage because we know how hard it was to gain, and how easy it is to lose. JSB Home Solutions would be a good fit for you if you are looking for a company who:

• Offers a blend of shorter job timelines without sacrificing quality craftsmanship
• Will provide high-value products without breaking the bank
• Warranties that cover not only the product itself but our installation as well
• Will listen to your goals and vision to turn your kitchen dreams into reality

We are passionate about what we do. We are rewarded every time we complete a job and see a homeowner like you fall in love with your home all over again. The key to success when working with any kitchen remodeler is clarity of information. To ensure proper communication, write down any questions to ask your kitchen remodeling contractors and record their answers side-by-side. By seeing how the companies compare on the details that matter most to you, you can be confident in your choice of contractor for your kitchen renovation project.