The 15 Best Bathroom Remodelers in Columbus, OH

Jump to List

You have always dreamed of running to your heavenly bathroom after a long day of work or taking care of the kids to soak in the tub. But instead, your bathroom has become a proverbial pain in your backside. It has not aged like fine wine and needs some TLC. The thought of trying to find a reliable contractor to give you a bathroom oasis has you running to the bathroom for other not-so-pleasant reasons!

With over 150 businesses listed by Google when searching for “bathroom remodelers in Columbus, OH,” where do you start to find a company with a stellar reputation for quality, value, and efficiency?

Naturally, we want to tell you that JSB Home Solutions is the best bathroom remodeler in Columbus, OH!  Our founder, president, and namesake has been a part of the remodeling industry since 1978.  We are proud to be a family-owned and operated business that values serving our customers with integrity, trust, and quality craftsmanship above all else.

However, we have not included JSB Home Solutions in the list because you are not here to read about why we think you should choose us for your bathroom remodel. While we would be honored to be entrusted with your bathroom project, that doesn’t necessarily make us the best fit for your needs.

As we introduce our guide to the top 15 bathroom remodelers in Columbus, Ohio it’s important to understand the three primary categories of remodeling services.

1. Facelift: If you’re looking for a swift and straightforward enhancement to your existing bathroom, a quick update is ideal. This involves applying a new surface layer, such as a skin, cover, or veneer, over your current setup, providing an instant refresh without extensive work.
2. Remove & Replace: At JSB, our specialty lies in the remove & replace approach. This method entails stripping out the old elements of your bathroom and installing brand-new materials. This process is thorough yet doesn’t typically require significant structural alterations to your home.
3. Design-Build: For those dreaming of a completely unique and tailor-made bathroom, design-build (also called full-scale or custom) remodeling is the perfect choice. This option allows for limitless creativity and customization, leveraging the full expertise and capabilities of your chosen remodeling team to transform your space completely.

We love remodeling homes and seeing people like you fall in love with their homes all over again. That’s why we have spent hours gathering information from the top 15 bathroom remodelers so that you don’t have to!  We have searched their websites for services offered, compiled star ratings, and other company information so you can compare these companies side-by-side to make the best choice for your home renovation project.

So here they are! These are the 15 best bathroom remodeling contractors in Columbus, Ohio ranked by their Google star rating.  Tie-breakers are determined by which company has the higher number of ratings.

1. Scott Hall Remodeling

“We have many years of experience in designing and working with our clients. We can create any type of customized interior remodel to meet your specific needs. Your project requires a combination of design, planning, budgeting, and management in order for you to have an enjoyable remodeling experience.”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 5 (51)
• Remodeling Category: Design-Build
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 25
• Franchise or Local: Local
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: A+
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: 5 (1)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 4.9 (152)
• Showroom: Yes
• Bathroom Services: All Bath Components

2. Simple Bath + Kitchen

“Looking to build a lavish lavatory or an awe-inspiring washroom? Or are you simply looking to modernize your aging bathroom with a few upgrades? No matter the extent of your project, we have a complete catalog of renovation services and custom solutions to cover your needs and bring your fantasy bathroom to life – and we get it done fast and on budget.”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 5 (25)
• Remodeling Category: Remove & Replace
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 12
• Franchise or Local: Local
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: A+
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: 5 (1)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 4.9 (218)
• Showroom: Yes
• Bathroom Services: Cabinets, Sinks, Lighting, Countertops, Showers, Tubs, Fixtures, Flooring, Toilets

3. Bath Tune-Up of North Columbus

“We provide a full range of custom design options as well as curated concepts for every level bath remodel. Tell us your vision and then sit back and let us handle the details.”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 5 (22)
• Remodeling Category: Remove & Replace
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 10 (35 years Nationally)
• Franchise or Local: International Franchise; Independently Owned and Operated
• BBB Accredited: No
• BBB Rating: –
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: – (0)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: – (0)
• Showroom: Not Listed
• Bathroom Services: Bathtubs, Conversions, Showers, Full Remodel

4. Nicholson Builders

“Remodel your home into a beautiful, restful space. Our meticulous architectural team and kitchen/bath designers guide you through every phase of planning for your particular project – from kitchen and bath renovation to major additions (and everything in between!)”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 4.9 (63)
• Remodeling Category: Design-Build
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 21
• Franchise or Local: Local
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: A+
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: – (0)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 4.9 (173)
• Showroom: Yes
• Bathroom Services: All Bathroom Components

5. Bath R Us in Columbus

“If you are intending to start remodeling your bathroom and your house, you will want to put your bathroom remodeling project in the hands of a team of bathroom remodelers you know you can trust.”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 4.8 (208)
• Remodeling Category: Same-Day
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 4
• Franchise or Local: Multiple Locations; based in Cleveland, OH
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: A+
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: 4.45 (64)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 5 (1)
• Showroom: Not Listed
• Bathroom Services: One-Day Baths, Bath Remodels, Shower to Tub Conversions, Tub to Shower Conversions, Replacement Baths, Bath Surrounds, Acrylic Wall Systems, Shower Replacements, Therapeutic Tubs, Walk-in Tubs

6. J.S. Brown & Co.

“As a full-service custom residential remodeling company and a licensed, bonded, and insured general contractor, J.S. Brown & Co. has built a solid reputation for quality workmanship. Our mission is to satisfy our customers’ needs by offering a better experience and end result at a value that can’t be matched anywhere else.”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 4.8 (39)
• Remodeling Category: Design-Build
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 46
• Franchise or Local: Local
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: A+
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: – (0)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 4.6 (39)
• Showroom: Yes
• Bathroom Services: All Bathroom Components

7. Re-Bath Columbus

“Whether you’re looking for a quick tub-to-shower conversion or an extensive bathroom remodel, Re-Bath will make the experience effortless. Our in-home consultations, high-end product selections, fast demos, and professional installation will take you from design to done in no time—and with no stress.”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 4.7 (114)
• Remodeling Category: Remove & Replace
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 14 (33 years Nationally)
• Franchise or Local: International Franchise
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: A-
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: 1.8 (5)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: – (0)
• Showroom: Yes
• Bathroom Services: Bathtubs, Showers, Tub to Shower Conversion, Shower to Tub Conversion, Accessible Bathrooms, Complete Bathroom Remodel

8. Columbus Bath Design

“It really is simple, because at Columbus Bath Design, bathroom remodeling is all we do. Your bathroom design will be handled by accomplished designers and the work conducted by Master Plumbers. We do not hire subcontractors.”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 4.7 (95)
• Remodeling Category: Same-Day
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 35
• Franchise or Local: Local
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: A+
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: 1 (1)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 4.7 (325)
• Showroom: Yes
• Bathroom Services: One-Day Bathroom Remodels, Showers, Shower Doors, Tub to Shower Conversion, Tile, Tubs, Vanities, Sinks, Faucets, and Accessories

9. The Bath Authority of Columbus

“Here at The Bath Authority, we are skilled at an extensive variety of Columbus bathroom remodeling projects and services. Whether it’s a fast new look with a new bath or through a more involved bathroom remodeling project, we keep your project on track with years of experience.”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 4.7 (62)
• Remodeling Category: Same-Day
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 3
• Franchise or Local: Midwest Franchise
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: NR (On Alert for Pattern of Complaints)
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: – (0)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 5 (2)
• Showroom: Not Listed
• Bathroom Services: Bathtubs, Showers, Bathtub/Shower Combo, Tub to Shower Conversion, Shower to Tub Conversion Walk-in Bathtubs, Shower Enclosures, Shower Liners, Shower Surrounds, Bathtub Surrounds, Bath Liners

10. ImproveIt Home Remodeling – Columbus, OH

“Updating your bathroom is as much about function as it is about fashion. That’s why you need bathroom remodeling that meets your lifestyle needs and your design dreams in one simplified process.”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 4.6 (890)
• Remodeling Category: Same-Day
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 35
• Franchise or Local: Midwest Franchise
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: A+
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: 4.75 (272)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 4.3 (175)
• Showroom: Not Listed
• Bathroom Services: Bathtubs, Showers, Walk-In Tubs, Tub to Shower Conversion, Bathtub/Shower Combo, Accessible Bathrooms, Accessories

11. Bath Fitter of Central Ohio

“With hundreds of custom designs, we fit your style. With our unique tub-over-tub installation in as little as one day, we fit your schedule. With quality that’s guaranteed for life, we fit your high standards. Why have over 2 million happy customers trusted Bath Fitter® with their bath remodels? It Just Fits™.”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 4.6 (246)
• Remodeling Category: Same-Day
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 29
• Franchise or Local: National Franchise; Independently Owned and Operated
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: A+
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: 1 (4)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 4.3 (82)
• Showroom: Not Listed
• Bathroom Services: Wet Space Only: Bathtub Liners, Tub to Shower Conversions, Walls, Showers, Accessories

12. SemBro Designs – Columbus, OH

“Ready to transform your house into your dream home? SemBro Designs is your one-stop shop for bathroom remodeling and all interior design aspects of your home. As a premier remodeler in Columbus, OH, we are a full-service company that will partner with you from the design stage of your project through the final cleanup.”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 4.6 (119)
• Remodeling Category: Design-Build
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 14
• Franchise or Local: Ohio Franchise
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: A+
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: 5 (4)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 4.8 (73)
• Showroom: Yes
• Bathroom Services: All Bathroom Components

13. The Cleary Company

“Simplify your next bathroom remodel project by selecting a curated design style and personalizing it for the exact look you want for your family. Or, work with our designers to create a completely personalize a new space you desire.”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 4.6 (29)
• Remodeling Category: Design-Build
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 30
• Franchise or Local: Local
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: A+
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: – (0)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 5 (27)
• Showroom: Yes
• Bathroom Services: All Bathroom Components

14. Mad City Windows & Baths – Columbus, OH

“When you’re tired of bathing in a dark, dingy, decades-old bathtub or shower, don’t suffer in silence! Instead, contact Mad City Windows, the home of one day bathroom remodeling. More than just a locally-based and family-owned business, we’re also Wisconsin’s #1 ranked remodeler—and we’re here to help you totally revamp your bathing environment in as little as a day.”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 4.5 (67)
• Remodeling Category: Same-Day
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 25
• Franchise or Local: National Franchise
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: A+
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: 4.55 (1474)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 4.8 (1876)
• Showroom: Not Listed
• Bathroom Services: Bathtubs, Showers, Walk-In Tubs, Tub to Shower Conversion, Shower to Tub Conversion, Bath Liners, Walls

15. Dave Fox Remodeling

“As an employee-owned home design & renovation firm, we are committed to serving our customers and employees by delivering high levels of quality and value through innovative designs, unparalleled craftsmanship, exceptional materials, and professional services.”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 4.4 (77)
• Remodeling Category: Design-Build
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 42
• Franchise or Local: Local
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: A+
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: 2.33 (5)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 4.4 (131)
• Showroom: Yes
• Bathroom Services: All Bathroom Components

How to Read a Remodeling Contractor Website – Teachable Moments

Kitchen Solvers of Columbus

Kitchen Solvers of Columbus has a page on their website for bathroom renovations. However, we were unable to find any pictures on their website or social media pages of actual bathrooms that they have renovated. They may be working on expanding into this area of home remodeling and have just gotten this page of their website set up. It would be prudent to ask for samples of completed projects if you choose to contact Kitchen Solvers of Columbus.

“Why wait to transform your bathroom into a spa-like retreat? Kitchen Solvers offers high-quality cabinets in a variety of sizes and styles. We’ll meet with you for a consultation to talk about your perfect bathroom and show you several vanity, countertop, and other options.”

*No bathroom pictures on website or Facebook*

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 5 (62)
• Remodeling Category: Remove & Replace
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 11 (42 years nationally)
• Franchise or Local: National Franchise; Locally Owned and Operated
• BBB Accredited: Yes
• BBB Rating: A+
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: – (0)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 4.8 (22)
• Showroom: Yes
• Bathroom Services: Not Listed

Creative Bath Renovations

Based on their website, Creative Bath Renovations appears to be a general contractor business model, meaning that they will manage any of the contractors that work on your bathroom but don’t do the work themselves. It is a little bit unclear if they have their own installers or if they only work through subcontractors. Clarity is key so ask questions about what it would look like to work with Creative Bath Renovations as you interview remodeling companies.

“I have always had a passion for architecture and great design. Working on a long, detail-oriented project takes a kind of patience and dedication that I pride myself and my team in having.”

• Google Star Rating out of 5: 4.9 (54)
• Remodeling Category: Design-Build
• Number of Years in Business in Columbus: 10
• Franchise or Local: Local
• BBB Accredited: No
• BBB Rating: –
• BBB Star Rating out of 5: – (0)
• Angie’s List Star Rating out of 5: 5 (25)
• Showroom: Not Advertised
• Bathroom Services: All Bathroom Components

How do you choose the right bathroom remodeling contractor for you?

Having options to choose from as you search for a bathroom contractor is great!  Having too many options to choose from sets you up for a headache and sends you barreling down the path to decision fatigue. Ultimately, you need to find a remodeler that will take care of you and your home as if it were their own. That’s why we have introduced the 15 best bathroom remodeling contractors in Columbus, OH: to help you determine what to look for in a reputable remodeler.

Our information would be incomplete if we did not tell you who JSB Home Solutions is a good fit for. We could list our 46 years of experience in the remodeling industry, our 4.7-star Google Rating, and our A+ rating and 4.33-star rating with the BBB. All the ratings, reviews, lists of services, and other qualities are great but they don’t really tell you who JSB Home Solutions is. JSB is driven by principles of integrity, trust, and quality craftsmanship and we are proud of our reputation because we know how hard it is to build, and how easy it is to lose. JSB Home Solutions would be a good fit for you if you are looking for:

• Efficient Project Timelines: Our bathroom renovation timelines are longer than over-existing remodelers but nowhere near the length and intensity of a design-build project.
• Quality Products: We want to add value to your home with quality products which means we may not necessarily be the lowest cost. But we are confident that you are getting the best bang for your buck.
• Craftsmanship Warranty: Our products come with manufacturer warranties but we also warranty our installation of the products.
• Your Goals are Top Priority: We will listen to your goals and vision to make sure that the bathroom we build is perfect for your needs. Designing and planning your project is part of the in-home consultation process.

We love seeing homeowners like you breathe a sigh of relief when you see your finished bathroom as your retreat from the busyness of life. The most important piece when interviewing bathroom remodelers is clarity of information. To ensure proper communication, write down your questions to ask your bathroom remodeling contractors and keep track of each company’s response. Doing this will help you know which company best fits your family, home and budget for your bathroom renovation project.